www射-国产免费一级-欧美福利-亚洲成人福利-成人一区在线观看-亚州成人

Domestic Affairs

Are Westerners in China more socially virtuous than Chinese?

By Patrick Mattimore (chinadaily.com.cn)
Updated: 2011-06-18 10:35
Large Medium Small

If you haven’t already read Liu Shinan’s opinion on the editorial page of Wednesday's China Daily, give a look (Recovering a long-lost social virtue).

Whether you agree with Liu Shinan or not, he broaches a compelling topic. Liu supposes that Chinese can learn from Westerners how to better safeguard social order and justice. As an example, he cites the case of the expatriate stopping a car that was going the wrong way on a one-way Guangzhou street.

To buttress his supposition, Liu cites a personal example of a foreigner who had yelled at him many years ago when Liu’s reckless driving nearly caused an accident.

Liu’s conclusion is that Westerners have developed a stronger sense of civic duty while Chinese have “become inured to petty violations of the country’s rules and regulations.”

As a Westerner, I would like nothing more than to ride in on my high horse and slip on a hero’s white hat. I’m just not quite sure it fits.

Here’s my own example. This past weekend my wife and I were about to board a bus in our Haidian neighborhood when we noticed a commotion between a young man and a young woman. He was grabbing her roughly. She was trying to get away and he threw a giant suitcase at her. Other people were watching. I intervened and stepped between the two individuals.

Okay. So far we have the white knight hero scenario Liu describes. But the young man didn’t react the way a Westerner would have (nor at least the way I think most Westerners would have) reacted. Rather than turn his anger upon me (Western response), the young man tried to explain that this was his girlfriend and that they were perfectly capable of working things out. He was able to compartmentalize and direct his anger at his girlfriend while simultaneously addressing me respectfully.

I still thought the young woman was in danger and urged her to get away but she stayed close by and continued to take guff from him, though less physical stuff. I backed off the scene.

Now here’s the thing. I completely agree with Liu that all of us need to take more responsibility for enforcing social norms. I did the right thing by intervening and I also agree with Liu that none of the Chinese witnessing the events were likely to get involved. I just don’t happen to think Westerners do interventions any better than Chinese but psychological science may explain why they appear to- at least in China.

First, one of the most researched and best understood phenomenon in psychology is bystander apathy or the bystander effect. The preeminent research on the topic was done by Princeton psychologist John Darley and his colleague Bibb Latane. Following in the wake of the Kitty Genovese murder case in New York City in which a young woman was stabbed many times while numerous neighbors watched but failed to intervene, Darley and Latane conducted laboratory experiments to understand why.

What the researchers found was that the chances of someone being rescued in Genovese situations or indeed in more mundane situations like the one I faced this weekend, is inversely proportional to the number of bystanders- i.e. the more people watching the less chance of intervention. The explanation is that people’s sense that they need to do something, even in situations of peril, decreases with more people because we take our social cues from the inactivity of others.

Responsibility is diffused and as Darley and Latane concluded: There is peril, not safety, in numbers. Now, I’m no hero but I am familiar with the bystander effect which makes it more likely that I will intervene and also makes me a bad subject from which to draw a more general conclusion.

There is also a second, less-well understood phenomenon, that might suggest why a Westerner would enforce a rule or law in China whereas Chinese would ignore petty violations.

We are all subject to powerful situational factors that largely control our behaviors. Americans are no different than Chinese in wishing to fit in, i.e. not stand out, even though Westerners give lip service to individuality. In a situation that calls for an intervention, the more powerful situational command is to do nothing so as not to draw attention to oneself.

However, Westerners in China stand out anyway. We therefore don’t experience that “fit in” commandment the same way a Chinese person does. That may make it easier for Westerners in China to yell at someone going the wrong way down a one-way street or intervene in a fight.

Finally, next week I will be in San Francisco meeting with Dr. Phil Zimbardo, America’s most famous scientific psychologist. Zimbardo is best-known for conducting the Stanford Prison Experiment in the early 1970s where he demonstrated how powerful situational forces could cause normal boys to act abhorrently.

Zimbardo’s current research focuses on advancing everyday heroism by ordinary people. I’m pretty sure he’ll have some ideas about ways to develop a stronger sense of our civic duties in China too.

Patrick Mattimore is a fellow at the Institute for Analytic Journalism, a former high school psychology teacher, and an adjunct instructor of law at Tsinghua/Temple Law School LLM Program in Beijing. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of the China Daily website.

分享按鈕
主站蜘蛛池模板: 九九热爱视频精品视频高清 | ffee性xxⅹ另类老妇hd | 久草在线免费新视频 | 日本免费视 | 一级毛片日韩 | 亚洲一区免费观看 | 成人性视频在线三级 | 欧美日韩一区二区不卡三区 | 暖暖视频日韩欧美在线观看 | 国产一区精品在线观看 | 久久久久久久久综合 | 男人的天堂免费网站 | 国产婷婷一区二区三区 | 亚洲视频日韩 | 国产一级视频免费 | 久久免费播放视频 | 日韩视频一区二区三区 | 精品外国呦系列在线观看 | 一级做a爰片久久毛片美女 一级做a爰片久久毛片免费看 | 国产精品免费视频一区 | 欧美三级成版人版在线观看 | 91网站网站网站在线 | 亚洲欧美日韩综合久久久久 | 日韩一区二区三区精品 | 丁香伊人五月综合激激激 | 色综合视频一区二区观看 | 成人不卡视频 | 中国二级毛片 | 国产精品男人的天堂 | 精品欧美一区二区三区精品久久 | 国产中文99视频在线观看 | 色吊丝在线观看国产 | 国产成人午夜精品免费视频 | 日本高清视频在线观看 | 色国产精品 | 在线观看视频99 | 在线看免费观看韩国特黄一级 | 国产免费人成在线看视频 | 国产成人精选免费视频 | 欧美一级一极性活片免费观看 | 免费一级毛片视频 |